I love the idea behind this collection and the design of the products themselves are super cute. I love the color range provided and the brushes are nice. However, it is extremely short lasting as it is water based. Any kind of sweating makes it run or smudge, which makes it a no no for hot days, festivals, and any situation where you may get wet or sweat. Personally, I sweat when I do my makeup and it is almost impossible for me to be happy with the finished result as I have to keep touching up what I have already done. I also find that they are a bit thick for creating sharp lines, and I have to add a liquid base to make sharp clean lines. Unfortunately adding more fluid makes the liners less opaque so it really takes finessing. A long lasting formula would be an amazing improvement, even if that means you can't rehydrate with H2O. I'd give a 6/10.

It’s pretty expensive. I had lots of issues with shipping they lots my package it was extremely hard to get ahold of someone and actually help, but everyone was very sweet. The product is very bright but don’t so on smoothly it cracks because you have to put on multiple layers. And I used the dropped that Iv seen used with it and it suspended to be smudged proof and it is not.

Love the shades and colors it comes in. You are the artist and your face is the canvas, Makeup Murder provides you the tools.

My liner collection was delayed in shipping, but communication was kept up always with an actual person and not just an automated bot. I was offered many free gifts for the inconvenience. Other than that, I have always received everything pretty quickly. This was the third order I have placed.

I absolutely love the Toxic Waste Eyeliner collection and all the colors. Customer support was also super nice when I reached out about my order. Overall amazing company and products.